Every rank sign-off, merit badge, board of review, and Eagle packet — tracked in one place, entered in a fraction of the clicks, and still exported to Scouting America when your council needs it.
| Job | Scoutbook (a real session) | TroopPlanner |
|---|---|---|
| Load the advancement dashboard | ~720 ms | 91 ms |
| Load the unit roster | ~1.0 s | 260 ms |
| Load the adult roster | ~855 ms | 240 ms |
Scoutbook figures are observed server response times from a real advancements.scouting.org session; TroopPlanner figures are p95 from its nightly load test on the production server. Compared the same way — time for the server to return the page's data.
The Requirement Matrix — select one or more requirements and one or more scouts, and sign off exactly what happened.
In Scoutbook: its one mass option marks every selected scout as passing the same requirement — all-or-nothing.
Requirements get completed at the campfire, not at the kitchen table. TroopPlanner's phone app installs straight to your home screen, with no app store needed. It keeps working when the signal doesn't.
The full blue-card lifecycle without the paper shuffle.
In Scoutbook: badge progress is buried and slow to update.
Outside merit-badge counselors sign off without ever creating a login.
In Scoutbook: connecting an outside counselor is a well-known headache.
From tracking the trail to printing the official application.
In Scoutbook: the Eagle packet is assembled by hand from scattered data.
The Eagle Scout Rank Application is the Scout's own work, so TroopPlanner puts it in the Scout's hands.
The committee-facing side of advancement, organized.
In Scoutbook: BOR prep and POR credit are manual bookkeeping.
The recognition workflow, from earned to presented.
In Scoutbook: no Court of Honor planning — it's a spreadsheet and a script.
Bring ranks, merit badges, and rank requirements in from a Scoutbook CSV — duplicate-safe, with a dry-run preview. Then export a Scouting America Internet Advancement upload file, with a divergence view showing exactly what differs from what's been reported.
Free for troops with 15 or fewer Scouts. Import from Scoutbook — your advancement history comes with you.